Archive for the ‘irex dr800sg and kindle dx compared’ tag
How will the iRex DR800SG eReader Compare with the Sony Daily Edition and the Kindle DX? 1 comment
This week iRex announced that its new and unfortunately named DR800SG ereader will be coming to a Best Buy store near you at the end of next 
month. The new ereader will have worldwide wireless connectivity provided by Verizon Wireless. Barnes and Noble and NewspaperDirect will be the partnered content providers for the DR800SG.
Because of its price of $399 and a touch screen with a size of just over 8″ it looks like the DR800SG will primarily draw comparisons to the Sony Daily Edition and the Kindle DX
Some of the features of the DR800SG:
- 8.1 inch e-Ink based display
- 3G wireless connection provided by Verizon
- Supports a number of DRM and open based formats, including Adobe PDF, EPUB, Newspaper Direct, Fictionwise, eReader, TXT
- Touchscreen
- Weighs 10 ounces
- Note taking will be added later with a free firmware update
- Comes with a pre-installed 2GB SD card (holds up to 1,500 ebooks); can be user upgraded to a larger capacity SD card
- Comes with a leather cover
- Battery is replaceable by user
The DR800SG ereader has a rather minimalist design. Some will find this refreshing as an ebook reader’s purpose should be to read books; the less distractions caused by the device itself the better. On the other hand, if you like to have ereaders in all colors of the rainbow to choose from and lots of hard controls to mess with you may not be taken with iRex’s design choices.
Some thoughts on how the iRex DR800SG, Sony Daily Edition, and the Kindle DX ereaders compare (realizing, of course, that neither the DR800SG or the Daily Edition ereaders are out yet to get an actual hands on with):
Wireless connection:
- iRex DR800SG will only let you connect to purchase ebooks and periodicals. No internet. Initially free, though iRex has left open the possibility to charge for airtime later on. The DR800SG will use Qualcomm’s Gobi 3G module and service should be worldwide.
- Sony Daily Edition only lets you use the wireless connection to connect to the Sony eBook Store.
- Kindle DX lets you connect to the internet or do things like check your email in addition to downloading ebooks and periodicals via the wireless feature.
Kindle DX is a pretty obvious winner here, but only if you live in the US.
Touchscreen:
- iRex DR800SG uses technology similar to a Wacom Tablet and a magnetic resonance stylus to avoid the glare and poor contrast issues of more conventional touchscreen technology. The iRex’s touchscreen is meant to be used with the stylus and not your finger.
- Based on what we’ve seen with the Sony PRS 600, the Daily Edition will have glare and contrast issues. The newer Sony ereaders seem to have less of these issues than the PRS 700 had, but they are still there. You can use either your finger or the stylus on Sony’s ereader touchscreen.
- Kindle DX of course has no touchscreen.
Probably the iRex will be the winner here. Glare and poor contrast are too distracting when you are trying to get lost in a good book. We will have to wait and see how well the touchscreen controls are implemented.
Content:
- It appears that the DR800SG ereader will be at home with Adobe Digital Editions as well as Barnes and Noble DRM’ed ebook formats. This would mean that you would have the same ebook sources as the Daily Edition ereader plus Barnes and Noble’s eBook Store. This gives you another outlet to shop for your desired titles and hopefully find lower prices. Newspapers and periodicals can be purchased from NewspaperDirect, which has 1140 newspapers from 87 countries in 41 languages in their original layout.
- Sony Daily Edition allows you to buy DRM’ed ebooks using Adobe Digital Editions. This means you can shop from several online ebook stores in addition to the Sony eBook Store. However, many of these shops seem to have pretty much the same titles at similar prices.
- The Kindle DX, of course, with access to the Kindle store offers many more titles (if you don’t count Google’s public domain titles at the Sony eBook Store and B & N), and in most cases offers Kindle format ebooks at a lower cost than you will find the same title in ADE format for.
I think the Kindle store makes the Kindle DX
Brand Recognition:
The average American shopper walking into Best Buy has probably never heard of iRex. However they have heard of Phillips Electronics, of which
iRex is a spin off. If said shopper has done any prior research into ereaders they will of course know that iRex has been making a series of higher end ereaders targeted primarily at the business user for some time and sold mostly in Europe. Also, I think that over the past couple of decades we have become increasingly used to finding our electronic devices made by new and upcoming manufacturers. Nevertheless, Sony no doubt has the advantage here, followed by Amazon.
In the end I think that Sony has the most to worry about with the introduction of the iRex DR800SG, but it should help make for an interesting holiday season in ereader land. I am looking forward to having a closer look at the new iRex ereader.
